Integrating existing systems with Artificial Intelligence (AI) is essential to staying ahead of evolving technology. Performance management and feedback are no exception: AI can streamline data collection, provide actionable insights, reduce bias, and support managers in delivering feedback. However, HR professionals should not rely solely on AI. While AI is a powerful tool for people managers, it should complement—not replace—meaningful performance management and feedback conversations. Successfully integrating AI into performance management means maintaining the crucial human element that fosters a positive workplace culture and drives genuine employee engagement.
Below are strategies for leveraging AI to enhance feedback while preserving the core human elements that drive engagement and growth to achieve this balance.
Strategies to Effectively Integrate AI in Performance Management:
- Support, Don’t Replace.
AI should act as a valuable assistant, not a replacement for human judgment. While AI excels in data collection and analysis, the critical qualitative assessments—those rooted in understanding and human context—should remain in the hands of managers. AI can highlight patterns, but it’s up to the manager to interpret the data and make decisions that are tailored to each employee’s unique circumstances.
- Make Informed Decisions.
AI-driven insights can provide valuable data that managers can use to inform their feedback conversations. However, managers should contextualize AI-generated insights with their own understanding of the employee’s work, personality, and goals. This ensures decisions are both data-backed and empathetic, aligning with the company’s culture and vision.
- Enhance, Don’t Automate, Feedback Conversations.
AI can help managers prepare for performance evaluations by organizing feedback and suggesting relevant talking points. But the conversation itself should remain personal, empathetic, and developmental. While AI is great at analyzing data, it cannot replace the value of a thoughtful, human connection during feedback sessions. Managers should use AI insights to structure discussions, but the heart of the conversation should be focused on growth, support, and genuine engagement.
- AI Isn’t Human—But It Can Support Human Connection.
While powerful, AI tools are not capable of active, empathetic listening—the kind that fosters real human connection. Managers can use AI insights to inform their conversations, but they should always prioritize listening and relationship-building. Managers ensure employees feel heard and valued by showing understanding beyond performance metrics.
-
Combining AI and Traditional Methods.
AI-driven feedback should never replace traditional methods of performance management. One-on-one meetings, informal check-ins, and other face-to-face interactions still play a vital role in creating a culture of feedback. When combined with AI insights, these methods foster a well-rounded, comprehensive feedback system. Employees can discuss their successes, areas for improvement, and personal development goals in a supportive, open environment.
viaPeople offers AI Instant Insights, a tool that helps managers synthesize multi-rater feedback into concise, actionable summaries. This tool provides valuable insights that drive better conversations by enabling managers to focus on meaningful discussions rather than getting bogged down by raw data. In addition, we offer training in emotional intelligence and interpersonal skills, empowering managers to handle performance reviews with compassion and understanding, while integrating AI insights to enhance the feedback process.
